It was Monday night, 21 September 1987, when AFL CEO Ross Oakley stepped up to the podium at the Hyatt on Collins in Melbourne to begin his first call of the medal count.
With the eyes of the football world on him, Oakley started with the first game of the first round, which was the Brisbane Bears’ shock Friday night win over North Melbourne at the MCG.
“One vote, Brisbane, P Walsh,” Oakley said, before going on to announce that the new Club had swept the votes, with captain Mark Mickan receiving two, and Brenton Phillips three.
As much as Phillips is remembered for his three-vote recognition of a match-winning five goals at half forward it is Walsh who went into the record books as the recipient of the Bears' first Brownlow vote.
Aged 27 at the time, Walsh had a game-high 31 possessions on the wing as the Bears, labelled a bunch of misfits and has-beens by the football media in the lead-up to their big-time debut, led at every
Walsh was recruited by Bears for the Club’s entry to the AFL after 22 games at Collingwood in 1983 and 40 games at Richmond in 1984-86.
After he left the Bears at the end of 1991 he was an
After this historic one-vote rating in the Bears’ first
Only one other time did he figure in the Brownlow votes when playing in Brisbane – when he earned two votes in a 25-point Round 17 loss to Fitzroy at Princes Park in 1987.
Still, 31 years on, he fills the number one spot on the Club’s list of all-time Brownlow medal vote-getters.
Forever he will be part of the Club’s rich Brownlow history alongside three Brisbane winners of the game’s highest individual honour and the eight Fitzroy winners before them.
Heading into the 2018 count in Melbourne on Monday night, Walsh is remembered as the first of 112 Brisbane players to have polled a total of 1856 votes, including 1996 winner Michael Voss, 2001 winner Jason Akermanis, and 2002 winner Simon Black.
Black has most Brownlow votes for the Club at 184 from Voss at 150 and Jonathan Brown at 112.
The Club’s top 20 vote-getters since 1987 are:
ALL-TIME BRISBANE | ||
Rank | Votes | Players |
1 | 184 | Simon Black |
2 | 150 | Michael Voss |
3 | 112 | Jonathan Brown |
4 | 93 | Nigel Lappin |
5 | 91 | Jason Akermanis |
6 | 83 | Luke Power |
7 | 68 | Tom Rockliff |
8 | 41 | Dayne Zorko |
9 | 39 | Adrian Fletcher |
10 | 36 | David Bain |
11 | 34 | Daniel Bradshaw |
12 | 33 | Matthew Clarke |
13 | 32 | Shaun Hart |
14 | 28 | Daniel Rich |
T15 | 27 | Pearce Hanley |
T15 | 27 | Jared Brennan |
T15 | 27 | Chris Johnson |
T18 | 26 | Alastair Lynch |
T18 | 26 | Michael McLean |
T18 | 26 | Dayne Beams |
Black has led the vote-count six times from Voss (5) and Tom Rockliff (5).
LEADING VOTE-GETTERS | ||
Player | LVG | Years |
Simon Black | 6 | 2002-04-07-08-09-11 |
Michael Voss | 5 | 1995-96-98-2000-03 |
Tom Rockliff | 5 | 2011-12-13-14-16 |
Jonathan Brown | 3 | 2006-09-10 |
Jason Akermanis | 2 | 1991-2001 |
Geoff Raines | 2 | 1987-88 |
Dayne Beams | 2 | 2015-17 |
Roger Merrett | 1 | 1989 |
David Bain | 1 | 1990 |
Michael McLean | 1 | 1991 |
Martin Leslie | 1 | 1992 |
Darryl White | 1 | 1992 |
Nathan Buckley | 1 | 1993 |
Craig Lambert | 1 | 1994 |
Nigel Lappin | 1 | 1997 |
Luke Power | 1 | 2005 |
Daniel Rich | 1 | 2012 |
Black’s winning 25-vote tally in 2002 is the most by a Brisbane player in a season.
MOST VOTES IN A SEASON | |||
Votes | Player | Year | |
25 | Simon Black | 2002 | |
23 | Jason Akermanis | 2001 | |
23 | Simon Black | 2008 | |
22 | Simon Black | 2007 | |
21 | Michael Voss | 1996 | |
21 | Tom Rockliff | 2013 | |
19 | Simon Black | 2009 | |
19 | Jonathan Brown | 2009 | |
19 | Michael Voss | 2001 | |
19 | Michael Voss | 2003 | |
18 | Simon Black | 2004 | |
17 | Michael McLean | 1991 | |
17 | Michael Voss | 2002 | |
17 | Nigel Lappin | 2003 | |
17 | Nigel Lappin | 2004 | |
17 | Luke Power | 2004 | |
17 | Jonathan Brown | 2007 | |
17 | Dayne Beams | 2017 | |
16 | Michael Voss | 2000 | |
16 | Des Headland | 2002 | |
15 | David Bain | 1990 | |
15 | Tom Rockliff | 2014 |
Twelve Brisbane players have had a total of 23 top 10 finishes, headed by Voss (6), Black (5) Brown (2) and Luke Power (2). Voss and Black have had three
Twice the club has had three players in the top 10 in the same year – in 2001 it was Akermanis (1st), Voss (equal 3rd) and Black (equal 10th) and 2004 it was Black (6th) and Nigel Lappin and Luke Power (equal 7th). Also, Black and Brown finished equal 4th in 2009.
Top 10 finishes have been:
TOP 10 FINISHES | |||
Year | Player | Votes | Finish |
1989 | Roger Merrett | 14 | T6th |
1990 | David Bain | 15 | T4th |
1991 | Michael McLean | 17 | T5th |
1993 | Nathan Buckley | 14 | T5th |
1995 | Michael Voss | 13 | T9th |
1996 | Michael Voss | 21 | 1st |
2000 | Michael Voss | 16 | T7th |
2001 | Jason Akermanis | 23 | 1st |
Michael Voss | 19 | T3rd | |
Simon Black | 12 | T10th | |
2002 | Simon Black | 25 | 1st |
Michael Voss | 17 | T3rd | |
2003 | Michael Voss | 19 | T7th |
2004 | Simon Black | 18 | 6th |
2004 | Nigel Lappin | 17 | T7th |
2004 | Luke Power | 17 | T7th |
2005 | Luke Power | 14 | T8th |
2007 | Jonathan Brown | 13 | 8th |
2008 | Simon Black | 23 | 2nd |
2009 | Simon Black | 19 | T4th |
Jonathan Brown | 19 | T4th | |
2013 | Tom Rockliff | 21 | T5th |
2017 | Dayne Beams | 17 | 9th |
Beams, who was also equal 7th in 2012 (19 votes) and equal 9th in 2014 (16 votes) when playing with Collingwood, is strongly favoured to head the Lions' vote-count on Monday night.
And if the votes awarded by the AFL coaches in the AFLCA Player of the Year Award are used as a guide, Beams, runner-up to Zorko in the Lions Merrett-Murray Medal, is in line for a career-best Brownlow finish.
This is based on a conversion of the 5-4-3-2-1 votes awarded by both coaches after each game in the AFLCA Player of the Year Award into notional 3-2-1 Brownlow votes - or ‘Coachlow’ votes - whereby Beams ranked fourth.
Under this
Other Lions players to figure in the notional ‘Coachlow’ vote count would be Zorko (7), Stefan Martin (6.33), Hugh McCluggage (5.5), Harris Andrews (3.5), Tom Cutler (2.5), Luke Hodge (2.5), Eric Hipwood (2), Jerry Berry (1.5), Mitch Robinson (1), Charlie Cameron (0.5) and Josh Walker (0.33).
According to the Coaches Votes, Beams will be in contention for maximum Brownlow votes as many as seven times in Rounds 9-10-11-15-16-17-22.
Zorko could get three votes in Rounds 7-8-20, Martin likewise in Round 3, McCluggage in Round 9, Andrews in Round 12 and evergreen Hodge in Round 14.
Fitzroy, too, had a wonderfully proud Brownlow Medal record.
At the time of the merger at the end of 1996 they had won eight medals to sit equal third on the all-time list behind South Melbourne/Sydney (12) and Western Bulldogs (9), and level with Essendon and St Kilda.
Add the three Brisbane medals and the Lions, with 11 medals in total, sit second behind Sydney (14).
The Fitzroy domination of the 1930s was extraordinary. Not only did they win the Brownlow five times in this decade via Haydn Bunton (1931-32-35), Wilfred ‘Chicken’ Smallhorn (1933) and Dinny Ryan (1936), but in the same period Bunton was 2nd in 1934, and Smallhorn was 6th in 1934, equal 3rd in 1938 and 5th in 1939.
Fitzroy’s 333-game games record-holder Kevin Murray had his own period of domination through the 1960’s. Not only did he win the medal in 1969 but he was 2nd in 1960, equal 2nd in 1962, equal 5th in 1963, 7th in 1964 and 3rd in 1968. He was equal 7th in 1967 despite stepping away from the Club in the prime of his career to captain-coach East Perth in 1965-66.
FITZROY BROWNLOW MEDALLISTS | ||
Year | Player | Votes |
1931 | Haydn Bunton | 26 |
1932 | Haydn Bunton | 23 |
1933 | Wilfred Smallhorn | 18 |
1935 | Haydn Bunton | 25 |
1936 | Dinny Ryan | 26 |
1950 | Allan Ruthven | 20 |
1969 | Kevin Murray | 25 |
1981 | Bernie Quinlan | 22 |
Allan Ruthven was 5th in 1946 and 6th in 1948 in addition to his win in 1950, while in more recent times, Garry Wilson was 3rd in 1978 and 2nd in 1979, and Paul Roos was 3rd in 1985 and 1986.
Murray was Fitzroy’s leading Brownlow vote-getter all-time with 178.
At the time of his retirement in 1974 he was second on the all-time vote list behind South Melbourne’s three-time winner Bob Skilton, and now, 44 years since his last game, he still sits equal 11th on adjusted votes all-time.
He slips ahead of Leigh Matthews because 57 of his 202 actual votes were received in 1976-77, thereby giving him an adjusted votes tally of 173.5.
LEADING BROWNLOW MEDAL | ||
Votes | Player | |
234 | Gary Ablett Jnr | |
227 | Sam Mitchell | |
218.5 | Gary Dempsey * | |
215 | Robert Harvey | |
210 | Chris Judd | |
191 | Brent Harvey | |
186 | Dane Swan | |
184 | Simon Black | |
181 | Joel Selwood | |
180 | Bob Skilton | |
178 | Kevin Murray | |
178 | Nathan Buckley | |
175 | Scott West | |
173.5 | Leigh Matthews * | |
* In 1976-77 votes were awarded under a two-umpire voting system, which meant twice as many votes were available to players. So, for comparison purposes, votes received in these years are halved. | ||
Geelong captain Joel Selwood went past Murray last year, and Collingwood captain Scott Pendlebury needs 14 votes this year to do likewise.
FITZROY LEADING VOTE-GETTERS | |||
Player | Games | Votes | |
Kevin Murray | 333 | 178 | |
Garry Wilson * | 268 | 138.5 | |
Haydn Bunton | 201 | 119 | |
Wilfred Smallhorn | 150 | 100 | |
Paul Roos | 269 | 98 | |
Allan Ruthven | 222 | 97 | |
John Murphy * | 214 | 83.5 | |
Grant Lawrie | 168 | 68 | |
Bernie Quinlan | 189 | 62 | |
Bill Stephen | 162 | 59 | |
Fred Hughson | 164 | 50 | |
Danny Ryan | 70 | 48 | |
Richard Osborne | 187 | 44 | |
Mathew Armstrong | 132 | 42 | |
* In 1976-77 votes were awarded under a two-umpire voting system, which meant twice as many votes were available to players. So, for comparison purposes, votes received in these years are halved. | |||
Among players who have played a minimum 50 games, Bunton has the highest votes-per-game ratio in League history. Having played 119 home-and-away games for 122 votes, his ratio is 1.025.
Next best to the end of 2017 is Fremantle’s Nat Fyfe (0.984) and Geelong’s Patrick Dangerfield (0.868).